Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-18 Clipper Ship Tea Company 0 views

Italian Grey vs Summer Grey: Which Flavored Black Tea to Choose

Italian Grey vs Summer Grey: Which Flavored Black Tea to Choose

Italian Grey and Summer Grey are both Ceylon-based Earl Grey blends, but they differ in herbs, creaminess, and availability. Compare ingredients, steeping, and serving ideas.

Two Earl Grey Variations, One Clear Difference

Italian Grey and Summer Grey both start with brisk Ceylon black tea and Italian bergamot, but they go in different directions. Italian Grey adds rosemary and lavender for a savory, aromatic depth. Summer Grey adds vanilla and orange for a soft, creamy cup. The choice comes down to whether you want herbal complexity or a gentle, dessert-like Earl Grey.

One practical note: Summer Grey is available in summer only, while Italian Grey is a year-round option. If you are reading this outside summer, Italian Grey is the one you can count on.

Ingredients and Flavor at a Glance

  • Italian Grey: Black tea, bergamot, rosemary, lavender, rose petals. Tasting notes: bergamot, rosemary + lavender. The rosemary and lavender add a subtle savory note, while bergamot stays bright. A well-balanced, smooth Earl Grey.
  • Summer Grey: Black tea, bergamot, vanilla, orange, cornflowers. Tasting notes: subtle Earl Grey with soft cream. A lighter, more delicate Earl Grey with creamy vanilla and a touch of orange peel, similar to a Lady Grey or Afternoon Grey.

Italian Grey: Catalog Details

  • Italian Grey: Ingredients: black tea, bergamot, rosemary, lavender, rose petals The herbal additions are what set Italian Grey apart from a standard Earl Grey; check them against your preferences.
    Italian Grey
    Italian Grey
  • Italian Grey: Steep 1 heaping teaspoon per 8 oz boiling water, 205–212°F, for 3–4 minutes This is the catalog steeping method; follow it to avoid over-extracting the rosemary and lavender.
  • Italian Grey: Excellent on its own and can take milk, sugar, or honey; also loved as an iced tea, and refreshing with sparkling water Gives you serving options beyond a standard hot cup.

Summer Grey: Catalog Details

  • Summer Grey: Ingredients: black tea, bergamot, vanilla, orange, cornflowers The vanilla and orange explain the soft, creamy profile; check for dietary preferences.
    Summer Grey
    Summer Grey
  • Summer Grey: Steep 1 heaping teaspoon per 8 oz boiling water, 205–212°F, for 3–4 minutes Same steeping method as Italian Grey, so you can use the same routine.
  • Summer Grey: Excellent on its own, lovely with lemon, and can take milk and sweetener; great as a London Fog base (brew triple strength, add vanilla and/or lavender syrup, and steamed milk) Suggests serving styles that suit its creamy character.
  • Summer Grey: Available in summer only This is a hard availability limit; plan your purchase accordingly.

How to Choose Based on Your Taste

If you enjoy herbal, savory notes in your tea, Italian Grey is the more adventurous pick. The rosemary and lavender make it a distinctive cup that stands up to milk but is also pleasant plain or iced.

If you prefer a softer, creamier Earl Grey with a hint of citrus sweetness, Summer Grey is the better fit. It is lighter than Italian Grey and works well with lemon or as a London Fog base. Just remember it is only available in summer.

Sizes and Value

Both teas come in four sizes: Small 50g (1.8oz), Medium 150g (5.3oz), Large 300g (10.6oz), and XL 454g (16oz). Catalog prices are USD 7.26 for Italian Grey and USD 7.10 for Summer Grey. If you drink Earl Grey regularly, the larger sizes may offer better value per gram, but the right choice depends on how often you brew and whether you want to stock up on a seasonal tea.

What the Catalog Does Not Confirm

The supplied information does not state caffeine content, allergen status, or shelf life for either tea. If you need those details, check the packaging or contact the store directly. Also, Summer Grey's summer-only availability means you may not find it year-round, so plan ahead if you want to keep it on hand.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile